Guest iPhone review from The Doc

This blog entry is from my brother.  He is a Doctor who recently acquired an iPhone.  I asked him to write a review from his point of view. And here it is …

As a physician (anesthesiologist), I have tried using both a Blackberry and a Palm Treo with only varying success as a useful tool for me; then along came the iPhone ...

The needs of physicians and different specialties vary, so our needs are different from a businessman.

Everyday,  I was carrying three devices to work: my cell phone, my Palm Pilot, and my iPod. Now, I carry one device.

The cell phone has long ago done away with the need for long-range pagers. My office or a nurse can call or text messages me on my cell phone at any time. This is true on all devices.

The Good:

The iPhone is great, yet I still use my old iPod in the operating room. Yes, we play music in the operating room. Patients enjoy listing to something familiar during their procedures. The operating room is my “office”;  I spend 80+ percent of my time in an operating room during the day. Myself,  the surgeon, the scrub and circulating nurses all enjoy listening to music during the day.

Because the operating room is truly my office, as I spend 7–10 hours per day in the OR, my “connectivity” needs are different than someone who has access to a laptop or desktop computer during the day. This is the area where the iPhone excels. I can get my e-mail, text messages, phone messages, etc. very easily on the iPhone. The other area which I find the iPhone to be far superior to its competitors is in its Web-browsing capability. Our hospital has an EMR (electronic medical record). I can access this from the OR by using my username and password. The ease of expanding the screen and point and touch (instead of point and click) is great. I can check orders, test results, check EKG's physician consultations, and radiology reports online very easily. This was not possible, or very difficult, on the Blackberry and Treo. I can also do online physician order entry and “electronically sign” my orders with the iPhone. Even though I cannot download a medical application, like the drug database epocrates, onto the iPhone, I can access it online very easily using my username and password.

The iPhone has really made my life much easier. Instead of scurrying around in-between cases to get to a computer to get info, I do it with ease. If there is something missing or awry with my next patient, I know about it ahead of time, can call the nurse in the preadmissions unit or consulting physician, and get clarification before the patient is ready to go to the OR.

The Bad

What comes on the iPhone is what you get. I cannot download medical applications, like drug databases or text material onto the iPhone the way I could on my Palm Pilot.

Why did they make the headphone jack too deep – so that I need to buy a $15 extender??

The iPhone is not friendly when answering a phone call in the car. It takes too many steps. First, I have to slide the unlock button, then answer the phone, then tell the iPhone whether I want to answer it by my Bluetooth, the speaker phone, or the regular phone. This is a 55-mph wreck waiting to happen, and I’m too young to be an organ donor!

 It also doesn’t have the one-touch “Call my brother at work” voice commands. With all the bells and whistles that this well-designed device has, it should have voice-activated calling!

The phone function works well and the quality is good, just not in the car!!

iPhone -- First Days, First Reactions: The Good, Bad and Ugly!

I have been using my iPhone as my main mobile device for the last 5 days.  I did this by having my main mobile number forwarded to my iPhone.  During this time, I used the phone at "work," at “play” and while traveling to Florida.  Here are my initial findings:

  First, the Sexy non-phone aspects: 

+++++++++++++The Pluses+++++++++++++ 

If you want to attract a crowd – just whip out your iPhone.  I have gotten lots of  “oohs, aahs, wows and omgs.”  It enhances your sense of self-worth and may even make you more sexy. (Although you have to read my wife’s blog to find that out!) 

I downloaded the movie “Miracle” to watch on a plane.  I chose this movie because I can watch it a hundred times and not got bored.  It is a classic – almost as good as “lap Shot”.  (But that’s the subject of another blog)

Watching movies on the iPhone is spectacular.  It is a very good (not great) personal movie player.  The movie player would be better with a few more DVD-like controls such as slow-forward and back, frame-by-frame, etc.  You can slide the time forward and back, but not with much precision. 

The Safari Web browser works well once you get the hang of it.  The Edge network is okay, not great.  3G would be much better, probably at the cost of battery life.

The photo viewer with position sensing is a real “showy” feature.  The ability to flip through an album on the iPhone, as you would a real album, is nice.

The music player is a latest-generation iPod.  I really like the carousel album selector.

The So-So features:

 The e-mail function is cool.  It would be cooler with a Blackberry client or activesync for corporate e-mail.

The camera is okay, but not the best feature.

   Google Maps gets a so-so from me because it lacks the killer feature: GPS. 

 It does however make for a great game to kill time.  Try this: Without typing in the address, try to tap into each Major League stadium and check out if there is a game!  You get an extra point if you can tell who is playing, and 10 points for the score!

Keyboard:

I have to admit that it is better than I expected, but nowhere near that of a real keyboard.  I am able to type using one finger (my pinky).  My letter accuracy is about 70%.  If I try the normal two-thumb method that I have used on Blackberrys and Blackjacks, my accuracy falls to near 0%.  So, I would say that the keyboard is slightly better than triple-tapping phone keys, and far less than a real keyboard.

 --------Some Negatives:------------

 The headset plug:

I was eager to watch a movie on my recent plane trip using my noise-cancelling headset.  I plug them into the iPhone and they canceled out ... everything.  After a moment, I figured out that the plug on the supplied iPhone headset is not standard.  I am sure there will be many adapters available.  This served as an annoyance on my first movie experience. 

 The phone features:

The phone features, surprisingly (or perhaps not), are the least-impressive features of the iPhone.  The voice quality seems very suspect.  People I called really noticed a reduction in voice quality.  Several relatives were not able to recognize my voice!  To verify that this was not the network, I called them back with my AT&T Blackjack, and there was no problem.

I still have not figured out how to download ringtones. 

Where is the MMS?

I sent an MMS message from a VZW phone.  The message arrived as an SMS that instructs me to go to a website (www.viewmymessage.com) with a specific login and password to view the multimedia message.  This is a great solution for 1997, not 2007, and certainly not on the most advanced piece of mobile gear ever produced!!

 Interestingly, MMS messages I sent  from AT&T phones never arrived on the device.

 It appears to me that the phone features were given low priorty,

 Battery Life: 

The battery life – as I predicted – seems to be an issue.  I used the iPhone to watch my movie for about 105 minutes, made 34 minutes of calls, browsed the Internet for 57 minutes, listened to music for 25 minutes,  viewed photos for about 30 minutes and had about 5 hours of standby time.  This started around 7 am. By 6 pm, my iPhone was dead.

I am confident that if all you did on the iPhone was make calls, the battery life would not be an issue.  But if that is all you are going to, why buy an iPhone?

 We will have to see if this a big issue in the market.

 Lastly:  The Nana Test  

As the true test of these features, I gave my iPhone to my 70-something mother.  She was able to use many of these features without issue.  This is the real miracle.  She is not the most technically oriented person.  She has a Web TV from 1997.  The UI was intuitive enough for someone who has trouble mastering her simple Nokia phone.  This is a thumbs-up for the Apple UI engineers.

More on my iPhone trial in a couple of days.

Activation success!  Finally – I got my iPhone activated.  It took a new SIM card, opening an AT&T account for a non-iPhone, then using iTunes to upgrade the account.  To really test out the iPhone, I’ve decided to forward my regular business mobile phone to the iPhone for a week.  I will let you know what I think of the phone next week. 

Speaking of iTunes:  I have to give two big thumbs up to the developers of this amazing application.  I know there have been compatibility issues in the past, but this new version seems totally awesome.  The integration with the iPhone and iStore appears seamless.  The graphical interface is compelling, the navigation is engaging and easy.  The application is fast, the Web integration is great.  Wow, Wow, Wow!  Nice job from the Jobs boys!

Caught in IPhone activation maze! 

So- I got my long awaited Iphone – Nice and shiny, futuristic, almost alien-like

Now all I have to do is activate it, easy ? Well here is the long story (It does not end well)

I want to activate my Iphone on the pay as you go plan, not a monthly subscription.  I take my iphone, plug it into my PC and volia – Itunes starts an activation process. 

 I think, “This is promising, so far so good” 

I had been  told by a “reliable” source that if you enter a bogus SSN (999-99-9999) you will be kicked into a pay as you go plan and then you enter your credit card and all is good to go. 

  I follow that path and after 5 minutes of thinking , Itunes gives me a message that I will receive an email with further instructions.

I check my email, and I have an email from Apple that says …. You guessed it… that I will receive an email with further instructions.

Ten minutes later I get a another email with a 800 number and a 14 digit code.  I call the number and give the guy the code and the fun really begins.

It seems my web account is somehow locked to postpay and he does not have authority to change it.  He is from the Iphone activation company and is the hero in the comedy that is about to insue.

He first assures me that AT&T customer care can make the necessary adjustments and makes a three-way call with a representative.  After explaining my dilemma, the rep asks for my phone number, which , of course I do not have.

  Before I know it , the activation rep and I are on the line with AT&T porting.

As you probably already guessed, Porting is for people transferring their number to AT&T, not for people who do not have an AT&T number and want one.  This flaw in our solution path is quickly realized by all parties .  We are then told that the Pre-Paid department is what we want.

My activation rep and I then call the AT&T pre-paid department.  Heather was very nice in explaining that they have nothing to do with Iphones and that we must call the special Iphone department.

 So- off we go on another call to the Iphone department.  My dilemma is explained to the rather stern representative at the Iphone department and when she learned that I had good credit and thus was post-pay eligible I was told that a pay as you go account was not an option for me.  I asked "Why?"

 I was told that you have to have bad credit to get a pay as you go account. 

 Uh? 

 I asked her if there was anyway they would be willing to accept my good credit money (which I think is worth the same or more than bad credit money) for Iphone usage?  I was told – no!  I asked – would you rather not have me as a customer?  Don’t you want the revenue?  And of course I was told – “Is there anything else I can help you with today, Sir?.....no……thank you for calling AT&T……click”

But- the story does not end there.    The activation rep who has been my guide in this adventure of hitchhiking through the Iphone customer service maze, decided that all of this just did not make sense.  He decided to contact his supervision and explain the situation.  Maybe that would enable me to give AT&T my money.

Another 10 minutes passes and the patient, but now defeated rep told me that the best advice he could get is to go to an  AT&T store and maybe they can help you. 

 I will try that tomorrow.   Do you think it will help?

As I stated in my previous installment, the big (really big) element of the iPhone is the screen.  

The large screen signifies the triumph of software design over hardware.  Gone will be the days of just programming a couple of softkeys.  

The iPhone subjugates the traditional phone functions to software display.  This design methodology requires more memory, a fast processor and lots of pixels to light on that display.  These elements all equal power consumption!  When combined with music, video, wifi and the occasional phone call, the stated power reserves seem aggressive.    

Similar to Rocket scientists who debate the use of weight capacity on a launch vehicle, the engineers at Apple must have had long debates on the allocation of power reserves to the various functions.  

Prediction: If the iPhone cannot last at least 24 hours with normal use – it will fail.  Expect extra-capacity batteries to be part of the iPhone, very soon.

The exciting and long-anticipated:

 iPhone – the final episode

Coming next week

The best part of the iPhone will be the most controversial.  Where is the keyboard?  Other devices have tried the soft-keyboard approach.  For those of us old enough to remember, the first one of note was the Apple Newton.  

Same hype, same paradigm shift.  The Newton left a big crater when it crashed, one that created “shock and awe” throughout a generation of devices. 

Next came the Palm.  The first successful soft-keyboard device for data.  This worked because the keyboard was still present – it was your PC.  The Palm succeeds because it was a remote data representation of data normally stored on your PC. 

When the Palm morphed into a wireless device – The Treo – it got a keyboard.  Why?  Because it now was a generator of data – not just “read-only.”  The Treo sends and receives e-mail and text messages, and therefore needs a keyboard.  

Now we are back to the Iphone.  No keyboard, but packed with connectivity, GSM with GPRS and Wifi.  As a phone, its owners will have a need to text and send e-mail.  Will the soft keyboard work for them?  I have serious doubts in this regard.  For those of us with larger fingers, or for those who have trouble with a Treo-sized keyboard, the idea of using a touchscreen keyboard for texts and e-mails seems daunting.

Prediction:  The next generation of iPhone will have a real keyboard.

Some more on the iPhone in my next iPhone installment.